Clojurians Log v2

I’m still having problems with lsp-lens-mode making smartparens commands e.g. slurp/barf etc intollerably slow (like several seconds). I’ve set the lsp-idle-delay to 1.0 and similarly for company-idle-delay, is there anything else I can do?

lsp-lens should not affect that I think, does the issue only happen with lsp-lens-mode enabled?

to be honest I’m not too sure, it seems slowest with it… but also slower than it used to be without it

It could well be something else

- command-execute                                                 785  95%
 - call-interactively                                             785  95%
  - funcall-interactively                                         785  95%
   + counsel-M-x                                                  560  67%
   - sp-forward-barf-sexp                                         136  16%
    - sp--indent-region                                           126  15%
     - indent-region                                              126  15%
      - lsp-format-region                                         126  15%
       - lsp-request                                              120  14%
        - accept-process-output                                     1   0%
         - timer-event-handler                                      1   0%
          + apply                                                   1   0%
       - lsp--apply-text-edits                                      6   0%
        - mapc                                                      6   0%
         + #<compiled 0x1fe085d5cab5>                               6   0%

Is there a way to switch of lsp indentation support?

Yes

lsp-enable-identation or something like that

We have a issue about indentation performance on huge buffers

current buffer is maybe just 200 locs

ok setting that to nil seems to improve things

so maybe the issue is indeed the indentation, could you check the logs between server and client and see how much time is taking each server response

via lsp-workspace-show-log

BTW this can help as well: https://emacs-lsp.github.io/lsp-mode/page/performance/

I created a issue to solve this problem on cljfmt: https://github.com/clojure-lsp/clojure-lsp/issues/266

🙇 thanks

incidentally it seems sometimes my smartparen commands like slurp forward are now generating garbled states, is that a known issue?

not really, could you elaborate with a repro?

not sure I’ve only seen it in a proprietary code base at the minute… but it looks like the parser is generating a syntax error where there isn’t one

hmm actually there is an error, but it’s really a semantic one… i.e. an unbound var that I’m trying to slurp forward a let over…

I suspect the broken highlighting is because of that too

that’s the before state above… If I slurp forward the let vanishes

(after state)

hmm I fixed it up by hand but still got the syntax error, however closing and reopening the file worked

It’s weird though because lsp indentation should also now be disabled

ahh maybe I need to restart the workspace…

yeah, that's definitively is a out of sync clojure-lsp error 😞 the same issue we are discussing yesterday on the channel

at least now we have a way to repro, that always happen with smartparens actions?

They seem prone to it

not sure if it’s always the case

only started using lsp in the past few weeks; so I’m still figuring it all out

yeah, I could not repro using paredit

I wasn’t expecting formatting to be baked in

ok, I suppose I could switch back to paredit at somepoint

we still need to fix it somehow on clojure-lsp side, but if you could test with paredit just to check if that makes any difference, would help a lot

I need to repro the issue to understand how to fix it

i'm getting lots of out-of-sync issues requiring reopening the buffer.

😕 Do you have a repro?

Maybe we will need to disable that by default

no, but using it for longer than 20 minutes i kinda can't not run into it

i made a function

(defun personal/kick-it ()
  (interactive)
  (let ((b (buffer-file-name (current-buffer))))
    (save-buffer)
    (kill-buffer)
    (find-file b)
    (inf-clojure-minor-mode)))

yeah, we need to understand when that happens, I suspect is related with some specific client changes, like a change with iedit , smartparens and etc

:clojure-lsp: Released 2021.03.16-20.28.06 version • Fix server not analyzing after a wrong code on cljs files - https://github.com/clojure-lsp/clojure-lsp/pull/367 • Rollback incremental didChange adding a new :text-document-sync-kind setting with :full as default. Check https://clojure-lsp.github.io/clojure-lsp/settings/for more details This release should fix the out of sync issues until we make the incremental changes stable.

Could you try latest release?

https://clojurians.slack.com/archives/CPABC1H61/p1615928058014500

one thing i remembered i had was the semantic tokens turned on, but i never really saw any benefit

i just turned it off, and gonna try it out to make sure that wasn't it

The semantic tokens should not affect that, they are only visual

also, clojure-lsp only support macros, but I'll add support for other things like functions calls etc just like CIDER add colors when repl is on

goodness

that's weird that it would highlight the f function binding and the entire call site

Yeah, I think that is another issue when you have a local variable that is a function call

I think it's a clj-kondo analysis range issue, but I need to test it locally and confirm that

ah ok

feeling better after upgrading

nice 🙂