Clojurians Log v2

in clojurescript, can states be named as non-strings?

the example cljs app in https://github.com/tolitius/mount/blob/0825ad2ed085b73b7ae989b4382ce4e0376e4be3/dev/cljs/app/example.cljs

names the app.audit-log/log state as a string like this: (js/setTimeout #(mount/stop-except "#'app.audit-log/log") 500)

@jiangts: the reason it is a string is because in :advanced cljs compilation mode, #'app.audit-log/log (as a "non string") would not work, since the app.audit-log namespace will be "optimized" into something like a.b, hence the state won't be found. whereas a string version of it will never change. is there a reason you would need them as non strings?

ah, gotcha. I was actually hoping to conceal some of my namespaces in the resulting output

@jiangts: you mean in the logs?

err, in the final js output

I might not be following.. where is this output go to?

like, after running the :advanced compile, a js file is produced

usually it is useful to have explicit "ns/state", to avoid confusion what comes from where

a.. ok, to minimize the js

right

how many states do you have?

a lot!

🙂

why so many? and how many is a lot?

haha, using it in clojurescript to manage all sorts of things ranging from dom event listeners to setIntervals to setTimeouts to atom watches

i'm writing a plugin javascript application where all the listeners attached to the DOM/js state need to be start-able and stoppable

a lot is maybe like, 50 or so states

but as the application grows, the # of states will likely also grow

might be an interesting mental exercise to figure out how to optimize the names. (not saying it is easily done, but still..) could you open an issue: i.e. something like "cljs: optimize state names in :advance mode"?

I'll think about it meanwhile.. js world and :advanced mode are quite hairy

haha, yes they are! cljs is my beacon of hope in a crazy front-end world 🙂

sounds good on the issue

great, thanks